Guide to Thermal Spray Welding (Metalizing)
Summary: The spray process is an umbrella name for multiple processes. All involve the use of a coating material in the form of a wire, rod or powder which is melted by one of the following sources of energy. The molten powder, wire or rod is accelerated and propelled towards the substrate by gas or an atomization jet. The particles build up and coat the material.
- Flame and Arc Welding (also called TSA, TSZ, TWAS): uses fuel such as acetylene or an electric arc to create required heat.
- Plasma Transferred Arc Welding (PTA): uses ionized gas and powder to coat materials
- HVOF (high-velocity oxyfuel): uses pressurized gas combined with powder.
- Detonation Gun Spraying: mix of gas, oxygen adn powder is ignited in gun barrel
- Cold Spray: Deformable particles are introduced to a supersonic preheated gas stream. Only plastic materials can be used.
The coating can be applied at different thicknesses. It is used to repair worn components and machine parts, or to improve performance and promote longer component life. Components frequently last 50% to 75% longer when treated.
Flame Spray Welding
Thermal Spray Welding Process Illustration
Arc Spray Welding
The Arc Spray process uses DC power to energize negative and positive wires which are fed through a gun head. The wires arc against each other in the head, creating the heat necessary for the creation of molten metal. Air that is compressed is introduced into the arc, atomizing the molten metal and then moving the droplets to the material being worked on. The droplets interlock on top of each other to create the weld or bond.
- Requires Amperage at or above Transition Level (short circuit then globular then spray arc)
- Transition - The point at which the weld pool changes. For
example, if the voltage is too low for the ipm then the wire will strike
the parent material, by raising the voltage to the transition level the
arc length will be increased to the short circuit transition level.
- In spray arc mode the wire forms a point (funnel) at the electrode wire end
- Very small droplets are formed and sprayed on the weld puddle
- 650 Amp power source
- Positive and Negative Power lead hookup
- Tow spools of Zinc, ZN/Al or Aluminum
- preheat surface to be sprayed (do not pre-heat aluminum, copper, titanium, manganese alloys due to oxide film formation. Best to under heat.
- one wire is energized positive and the other negative
- wires are fed through a spray welding system
- both wires meet at the gun head and create an arc
- dry compressed air atomizes the material and propels it
- spraying torch much be perpendicular to the surface otherwise porosity increases (avoid sharp edges, narrows holes)
Flame Spraying Process
The process uses one of a number of gasses for fuel:
Wire or powder is injected into the flame where it melts and is sprayed onto the work.
Equipment requirements are minimal and it can be applied off or on-site. It is also inexpensive.
Ignition occurs outside the torch
Spraying distance 100 to 200 mm
Advantages of flame spray include relatively low surface heating (350 to 450C), high deposition rates (60-95%), flexibility and simplicity of process.
The downsides of flame welding include low adhesion, high porosity, low heating efficiency and it is not possible to spray materials with a melting point over 2800C.
Plasma Spraying Process (PTA)
The plasma spray process was developed to spray ceramics, although plastics and metals can be treated. The process van be automated and requires fewer steps than other spray welding processes.
The plasma spray welding process has the greatest amount of versatility. Here a gas is used (hydrogen, helium, nitrogen, argon) with an electric arc ionizing the gas.
The process operates at over 10,000C, which is hotter than the melting point for metals. Powder is injected into the flame where it is melted and moved to the material being sprayed.
Advantages of plasma transferred arc welding process include that it is easy to apply, it has bigger size of cermet particles, it has a higher wear resistance, low or no porosity, thick coatings and low heating of the substrate when compared to GTAW.
Disadvantages include high oxidation of sprayed material and it is impossible to obtain thin coatings of 1mm or thinner.
High Velocity Oxyfuel (HVOF)
High-Velocity Oxyfuel Spray Welding
The High-Velocity Oxyfuel Process Used to Apply Chromium Carbide to a Ball Valve
The HVOF process combines gas (hydrogen, oxygen, propylene, air, kerosene), which is injected using high pressure into the torch's combustion chamber. Gas achieves supersonic speeds while at the same time powder is injected into the flame. The process provides dense thermal spray coatings with less than 1% porosity. The result has high bond strengh and fine as-sprayed surface finishes. Oxide levels are also low.
The process is used for spraying wear-resistant carbides and alloys (wear or corrosion resistant) such as Iconel, Triballoy and Hastelloy.
Spraying distance is 380 - 400mm.
The process has high levels of adhesion and low porosity (less than 1%). It supports thicker coatings and has a higher amount or retained carbides when compared to plasma or flame spraying).
It is relatively noisy (greater than 130 dB) with a low deposition rate (35% - 50%). Equipment also tends to be higher in price.
Detonation Gun Spraying
Detonation Gun Spraying Diagram
- A mixture of powder, oxygen and gas is ignited in gun barrel.
- The barrel is purges by nitrogen between detonations.
- Feed rate is 0,5 to 12 kg/h.
- Spraying distance is 50 to 200mm.
Advantages of the detonation gun spraying process include high adhesion, low porosity (less than 1%) and a high feed rate (up to 12 kg/h). The process has a higher amount of retained carbides when compared to plasma and flame spraying.
Disadvantages include that it is hard to spray materials with low density such as Iic, high noise (great than 140 dB), has a need for sealed boxes and a high price.
Detonation Gun Spraying Equipment
Cold Spray Welding Process Diagram
The cold spray process uses deformable particles that are introduced to a supersonic preheated gas stream. The stream is directed onto the substrate. The coating is deposited by an impaction process.
There is no heating of particles (the gas is heated to achieve a higher sonic flow speed).
Only plastic materials an be used.
Comparison of Coating Processes
Coating Process Comparison Diagram
Thermal Spray Welding Processes
Substrate Preparation Methods
- vapor de-greasing
- baking (porous materials are baked at 315-345C)
- ultrasonic cleaning
- dry/wet abrasive blasting
- roughening: 2 hours before spraying with machining, macro-roughening or dry abrasive grit blasting
Advantages and Disadvantages
- Smooth Weld Bead
- High Penetration (used on metal 3/16" or greater)
- High Weld Deposit rates
- Minimal Spatter
- Reduced cost: spray is used to strengthen a lower cost material
- Low heat input: coatings do not penetrate the base material
- Versatile: Most metals, plastics and ceramics can be sprayed
- Works within a broad thickness range: .001 to .1 inche, can be more than 1 inch thick
- Fast processing speed: spray goes on from 3 to 60 lb/hour (depends on the process being used)
- Requires welder training
- Gas Cost can be greater due to higher argon levels ( > 85%)
- Recommended for flat position and horizontal fillets only
- High Heat can cause welder discomfort
- Undercut can be caused, especially on the top edge of welds
- Bonding of coating is mechanical, not metallurgical
- Line of sight process
- Poor resistance of coatings to pinpoint loading
- Requires High Voltages, (usually 26 volts To 37 volts)
- Wire Electrode Size: (usually 0.045 or larger required )
- High Amperages (usually 180 Amps To 440 Amps )
- Shielding Gases: At least 85% argon remainder CO2. 92/8 is most commonly used.
- Machine settings can greatly effect the weld.
- High current/heat.
- Small machines not capable of spray mode.
- Machine duty cycle is an important factor.
- When setting machine parameters (volts/ipm) start with the
suggested setting then manipulate the voltage up or down until the sound
is 1/2 “crackle” and 1/2 “whoosh”
For Additional Reading
American Welding Society